Classic Fictional Universes That Could Outshine Marvel on the Big Screen
Marvel’s cinematic empire set the gold standard for universe-building, fan engagement, and blockbuster storytelling. But what if other beloved fictional universes, some decades old and others newer, stepped into the arena? Here are 10 classic universes with the muscle, mythology, and fandom to possibly beat Marvel at its own game.
Image from Sora
Which Classical Fictional Universes Could Beat Marvel at Its Own Game?
The Marvel Empire: Setting the Bar
Since 2008’s Iron Man, Marvel Studios has crafted a sprawling interconnected cinematic universe, raking in billions and winning hearts worldwide. Their recipe? Memorable characters, rich mythology, crossovers, and a perfect blend of humor and drama.
But Marvel’s dominance isn’t eternal. Other fictional universes—rich with stories and legions of fans—have the ingredients to challenge or even surpass Marvel’s grip on pop culture.
Let’s explore 10 of those universes, spanning decades and genres, that could beat Marvel at its own game — or at least give it a run for its money.
1. The Wizarding World (Harry Potter & Beyond)
- Cinematic potential: Massive — the original Harry Potter films proved this.
- Fanbase: Global, spanning multiple generations.
- World-building: Deep magical lore, diverse creatures, and complex social dynamics.
Though Harry Potter’s main series is complete, the Wizarding World continues expanding via Fantastic Beasts, theme parks, and stage plays. The core magic system and character-driven stories rival Marvel’s complexity.
If Warner Bros. fully embraced a connected cinematic universe for all Wizarding tales, integrating spin-offs and legends, it could match Marvel’s universe-building, tapping into a passionate fanbase hungry for more magic.
2. The Lord of the Rings / Middle-earth
- Cinematic potential: Epic world, history, and mythology.
- Fanbase: Staunch and enduring since the 1950s books and 2000s films.
- World-building: Tolkien’s detailed languages, histories, races, and geography.
Amazon’s The Rings of Power series shows that Middle-earth is fertile ground for serialized storytelling. With Tolkien’s rich lore, an interconnected series spanning ages, races, and stories could create a fantasy cinematic universe rivaling Marvel’s scale.
3. Star Wars
- Cinematic potential: Nearly unmatched in sci-fi adventure and mythic storytelling.
- Fanbase: Massive, spanning over 40 years.
- World-building: Complex galaxy of planets, species, politics, and Force mythology.
Star Wars has long been the original cinematic universe, with movies, TV series, comics, and novels. Disney+’s The Mandalorian and upcoming shows demonstrate ongoing expansion. Star Wars could easily outshine Marvel if it more aggressively connected all stories into a single, cohesive universe with crossovers.
4. The DC Extended Universe (and Expanded Comics Universe)
- Cinematic potential: Iconic superheroes rivaling Marvel’s roster.
- Fanbase: Loyal comic fans and mainstream viewers.
- World-building: Gods, aliens, dark mythologies, and multiverse concepts.
DC has struggled to replicate Marvel’s cinematic success consistently but owns some of the most recognizable characters in pop culture. With the multiverse concept, DC can explore countless storylines, dark and light, horror and epic, which gives it huge potential.
5. The Star Trek Universe
- Cinematic potential: Deep philosophical sci-fi with decades of series and movies.
- Fanbase: Devoted, intelligent, and spanning generations.
- World-building: Vast future history, alien species, and political intrigue.
Star Trek’s mix of optimism and complex narratives could create a cinematic universe focused on character and sociopolitical drama, setting it apart from Marvel’s action-heavy formula.
6. The Batman Universe (Pre/Post Nolan)
- Cinematic potential: Gritty, dark, and psychologically rich.
- Fanbase: Tremendous, from comics, games, and films.
- World-building: Gotham’s cityscape, rogues gallery, and vigilante mythology.
Batman’s noir tone offers a grounded alternative to Marvel’s cosmic scale. A shared universe focusing on Gotham’s characters—heroes, villains, and antiheroes—could be a compelling dark mirror to Marvel’s colorful world.
7. The Hunger Games & Dystopian Futures
- Cinematic potential: Relevant, gritty dystopia with strong characters.
- Fanbase: Young adult to adult crossover.
- World-building: Political intrigue, rebellion, and future societies.
While Hunger Games was a huge hit, expanding into a larger dystopian universe involving other similar worlds or sequels could capture audiences wanting darker, socially conscious narratives beyond Marvel’s scope.
8. The Marvel Zombies / What-If Universes (Comic Crossovers)
- Cinematic potential: Meta, self-aware storytelling ripe for expansion.
- Fanbase: Hardcore comic readers and cult fans.
- World-building: Multiple realities, alternate versions, and unexpected crossovers.
If Marvel itself can’t outdo Marvel, alternative Marvel universes in comics hint at how imaginative, varied universes can be — a potential source for spin-offs or rivals from other publishers could bring fresh energy.
9. The Studio Ghibli & Miyazaki Universe
- Cinematic potential: Magical realism and unique stories beyond superheroes.
- Fanbase: Global and passionate about animation and art.
- World-building: Fantastical worlds, deeply emotional narratives.
While Ghibli’s films aren’t connected in a cinematic universe sense, their consistent tone, aesthetic, and themes could be woven into a shared universe with original stories, appealing to an audience craving artful, emotional stories.
10. The Avatar Universe (James Cameron’s Films + Expanded)
- Cinematic potential: Immersive alien worlds and environmental themes.
- Fanbase: Huge since the original Avatar film in 2009.
- World-building: Rich ecology, culture, and sci-fi tech.
With multiple sequels planned, Avatar could grow into a vast interconnected universe focusing on different planets, cultures, and conflicts, directly challenging Marvel’s cinematic dominance with visual spectacle and ecological storytelling.
Why These Universes Could Beat Marvel
- Deep, Pre-Existing Lore: Many have decades of storytelling before Marvel’s rise.
- Unique Genres: Fantasy, sci-fi, dystopia, and animation offer fresh tones Marvel doesn’t always explore.
- Fan Loyalty: Longtime fans often crave faithful adaptations and expansions.
- Cinematic Innovation: New tech, storytelling styles, and distribution models level the playing field.
- Cross-Generational Appeal: Some universes span multiple age groups and cultures.
Could Any of These Universes Actually Overtake Marvel?
It’s complicated. Marvel’s edge lies in its broad accessibility and carefully calibrated humor-action formula. But any of these universes could carve a unique niche that outshines Marvel in storytelling quality, world-building depth, or cultural impact.
The race is wide open — and the future of cinematic universes is as exciting as ever.
External Sources
